310.275.5533
call or text
310.275.5533
call or text
Home » Ophthalmology Blog » VITAMINS: SCIENCE OR RELIGION? (1)

VITAMINS: SCIENCE OR RELIGION? (1)

Published: November 16, 2022

Some people adore vitamins and consume them in large quantities, while others totally reject them. However, the reality is, as usual, in the middle.
Рere we consider cases where they were useful and when it is better to rely on more evidence-based methods.

VITAMINS: SCIENCE OR RELIGION? (1)

VITAMINS: SCIENCE OR RELIGION? (1)

Some people worship vitamins and take them by the handful, while others reject them categorically, seeing them as a shady, billions-of-dollars scam.  But the truth, as usual, isn’t at either extreme or even in the middle, but scattered all over the spectrum.  After a lot of material came out on the demythologization of vitamins, on one hand, and their revitalization on the other, it’s easy to get confused.  And reading all of those articles is impossible, so it’s always better to ask a specialist.  Per our tradition, I interviewed Arthur Benjamin on the subject, and also recently read something myself about using vitamins for dry eyes. 

The drops you prescribed me for dry eye worked really well, so I’ve forgotten what I read about.

You read about Omega-3s.  The results of a serious study on the effectiveness of Omega 3s has been widely talked about in the media.  Many believe that they reduce the risk of heart attack, help with cardiac conditions, are effective against hair loss, improve the skin, and also work in the treatment of dry eyes.  They say to take these supplements, drink fish oil or flaxseed oil, and life gets better.  In this particular study, though, no differences were found between subjects that took the supplements and those who took a placebo – not in the dryness of their eyes or anything else.  From this, you could draw the conclusion that vitamins are useless in general.  And while it’s clear that they make sense in some parts of Africa with high rates of avitaminosis, it seems that we’re getting enough vitamins in developed countries where people eat a more or less balanced diet.

I feel like there’s a catch.

Yes!  BUT there’s also 30 years of data that cannot be denied about AREDS 2 vitamins used for macular degeneration.  A powerful study was conducted by the National Eye Institute, paid for by both the taxpayers and Bausch + Lomb.  Based on the physiology and pathophysiology of the disease, they developed a theoretical formula using retinoids (a group of fat-soluble vitamins), flavonoids (derived from dark, leafy greens), vitamins A and E, and zinc that was supposed to protect the retina from degeneration.  The formula was then released into the market and used on patients with AMD.  As a result, the progression of wet macular degeneration in those who took the formula slowed down significantly, as opposed to those who did not take the vitamins.  In short, their sight was better.

Remind us of what’s involved with AMD.

Age-related macular degeneration or macular degeneration (AMD) is the most common cause of loss of vision among the elderly.  It starts as the gradual destruction of the central field of vision, making it difficult for someone to read, drive, or recognize faces.

And this complex vitamin can help with that?

Yes, but there’s still a catch.  Smokers are four times more likely than non-smokers to have AMD, but taking this formula is contraindicated in this case, because the beta-carotene increases a smoker’s chance for lung cancer.  Therefore, for smokers, another formula is recommended that replaces the beta-carotene with lutein.

I have friends that are smokers and I care about them, so I gotta have more details.  So smokers shouldn’t eat carrots, for example?  Or how exactly is beta-carotene bad for smokers?

Despite the fact that the word “carotene” comes from the Latin word for carrots, “carota”, they are not a threat.  The study took place in Finland, which has an excellent health care system, and all subjects were supervised and registered.  They wanted to somehow lower the risk of lung cancer among smokers, so they studied the physiology of the disease and had the idea that they could neutralize the free radicals in smokers by using beta-carotene.  It became clear, though, that that vitamin has the opposite effect in some circumstances.  Thus, the risk for cancer increased, rather than decreased.

Maybe this is particular only to Finns, or perhaps the sample is too small?  Is it the same in other countries?

This study can be trusted, because it was constructed in the scientific canon.  However, hear this – everyone who has macular degeneration, and those who’ve read about the uselessness of vitamins for dry eyes, shouldn’t discount their benefits for the retina.  And in addition to the study I’ve already mentioned, other research was carried out on this subject 25 years ago where the formula was slightly different, and it worked.  So it isn’t a question of faith, but of knowledge.

What do you mean “it worked”?  It improved their condition?

Macular degeneration can’t be cured, so we’re talking about preventing future deterioration.  But unfortunately these wonderful vitamins are often the size of horse pills, so older people run the risk of choking, especially when they have to take multiple pills a day.  What’s interesting, though, is now a company has put them in powder form.  Simply dissolve it in water and drink, and the taste is almost like orange juice, so the whole process is rather pleasant.

I can’t stand huge pills.  You can’t just shatter them with a hammer?  It turns into powder. 

(to be continued)

Back

SEE WHAT OURPATIENTS HAVE TO SAY

Posted on Google Google
Jim B profile picture
Jim B
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Everyone is always pleasant and kind and attentive. Focused and on schedule.

Owner's reply
Thank you for your wonderful feedback, Jim! We're thrilled to hear you had a great experience from start to finish. Your recommendation means a lot to us! We look forward to serving you again in the future.
Posted on Google Google
Nick Ben-Meir profile picture
Nick Ben-Meir
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Efficient service, and Dr Benjamin ahead of the curve, as always

Owner's reply
Thank you for your 5-star review, Nick!
Posted on Google Google
sharon piehl profile picture
sharon piehl
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Everyone was very kind and I felt comfortable being there for the first time.

Owner's reply
Dear Sharon, Thank you so much for your kind review. We’re so glad to hear that you felt comfortable and well cared for during your first visit. We truly appreciate you choosing Benjamin Eye Institute and look forward to seeing you again. The Benjamin Eye Institute Team
Posted on Google Google
Luba Lubov profile picture
Luba Lubov
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Great experience and I recommend this eye doctor.

Owner's reply
Thank you, Luba, for your very kind words! Looking forward to seeing you soon at Benjamin Eye Institute!
Posted on Google Google
Peter Trivelas profile picture
Peter Trivelas
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Profesional, skilled, personal, friendly.

Owner's reply
Thank you so much, Peter! Your kind words mean a great deal to us!
Posted on Google Google
Marjorie Dick Stuart profile picture
Marjorie Dick Stuart
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Always the best! Beautiful office, beautiful , helpful staff, amazing customer service, all the best equipment, and the best doctor. They will take good care of you!

Owner's reply
Thank you so much, Marjorie! Your kind words mean a great deal to Dr. Benjamin and our entire team! We truly appreciate your trust!

Related Articles

What is keratoconus?

What is keratoconus?

November 21, 2022

We will open up about whether there is at least something beautiful behind these magic words – macular degeneration and diabetic retinopathy. What kind of unpleasant disease lies under such an interesting "keratoconus" and what is the connection with the cone?

more
Macular Degeneration, or Science of Yellow Spots

Macular Degeneration, or Science of Yellow Spots

November 21, 2022

Despite the fact that Macular Degeneration considered as a disease of kings, now it affects and leads to blindness not only to a privileged society. The light of hope was received from a group of American ophthalmologists who saved four patients from blindness with a new method that’s described in the Journal of Translational
Medicine.

more
ROBOT-SURGEON PERFORMED A PARTIAL OPERATION ON THE RETINA

ROBOT-SURGEON PERFORMED A PARTIAL OPERATION ON THE RETINA

November 20, 2022

For the first time in history, a robot called PRECEYES participated in an operation. The task was to dissect a specific membrane in the macula, a yellow spot of patients with macular degeneration. Results from six patients, operated on by robots, were compared with six others operated on by humans, but in terms of speed, you might be surprised that man won. Humans 1.5 minutes against robots 5.

more
WHAT DOES YOUR RETINA SAY ABOUT YOUR HEALTH

WHAT DOES YOUR RETINA SAY ABOUT YOUR HEALTH

November 19, 2022

The retina is a portal to your brain. According to new data, Alzheimer’s can show itself through some eye diseases that affect the retina. If problems begin in retina, it could be a symptom of physiological abnormalities in the brain. Also, retinal problems can indicate such diseases as diabetes, atherosclerosis. etc.

more
ORANGES, GIBBERISH, AND BLINDNESS

ORANGES, GIBBERISH, AND BLINDNESS

November 19, 2022

Researchers observed a sizable population for 15 years, which demonstrated that the probability of developing macular degeneration was 60% lower in orange lovers than in orange haters. Flavonoids, according to the study's author, are most likely what cause this impact. Numerous authors adore the word "flavonoids" because it is so lovely. However, what are they?

more
OPTOS the GREAT

OPTOS the GREAT

November 19, 2022

Future is officially here! Optos is the modern diagnostic equipment for systemic and ocular retinal diseases. With the assistance of Optos, ophthalmologist can take a fundus photo and see the rear of the eye for potential retinal tears.

more
BLINDNESS LOSES TO A GRAIN OF RICE

BLINDNESS LOSES TO A GRAIN OF RICE

November 18, 2022

Genentech has created a new delivery method for medications needed to prevent age related macular degeneration (AMD) called Port Delivery System. It resembles a small grain of rice that goes directly into your eye and time-releases medication. Genius!

more

SCHEDULE YOURCONSULTATION TODAY!